Welcome to Heintzelman’s BBQ Pit
Located at 6361 Knickerbocker Road in Ontario, Heintzelman’s BBQ Pit brings authentic pit-smoked barbecue to the community with bold flavor and traditional slow-cooking methods. Built on time, smoke, and craftsmanship, this local favorite serves up hearty plates in a welcoming, laid-back setting.
Fire, Smoke, and Serious Flavor
Low flames. Long hours. Deep, rich character in every bite. This is barbecue done with patience and precision. Each plate carries layers of smoky intensity balanced with savory richness and just the right hint of char. The aroma alone pulls you in, but the first bite seals the deal. Rustic, bold, and unapologetically hearty — this is comfort elevated with edge.
Order From Our Website
Skip the wait and bring authentic pit-smoked barbecue straight to your table. Ordering online is fast, simple, and convenient. Choose your favorites, customize your meal, and pick it up fresh and hot.
A Closer Look At Our Creations
Get a visual preview of what’s coming your way.
Reserve Your Table Today
Planning to dine with us? Secure your spot in advance and enjoy a relaxed, welcoming smokehouse experience without the wait. Whether you're joining us for a casual meal or gathering with family and friends, we’re ready to make your visit seamless.
For Reservations:
Call 315-333-1235 or 585-507-5210 to book your table.
Bring The Pit To Your Next Event
Let us handle the food while you focus on your guests. Our catering brings authentic pit-smoked barbecue straight to your event — prepared low and slow, packed with bold flavor, and served fresh.
From family celebrations to corporate functions and community events, we provide generous portions and dependable service that make hosting easy. Big or small, your event deserves barbecue done right.
A Place For Everyone
A welcoming space where great energy and good company come together. Enjoy flavorful happy-hour selections and expertly crafted cocktails.
Visit Us Today!! 🔥
Hours:
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: Closed
Wednesday: 4–8 PM
Thursday: 4–8 PM
Friday: 12–8 PM
Saturday: 1–8 PM
Sunday: Closed
What our guests are saying
The food it’s actually really good, they serve fast with also great service, price is fair, nice environment, family oriented, they support Military, Law enforcement etc I think that's a nice detail… really comfy chairs as well. Will come back to get food when am around, highly recommend!
Super C.
First time at this BBQ joint but not the last. Our waitress Michelle was great. So very friendly. We were offered a sampler of their favorite sides, so picking ours with our dinners wasn't so hard to do, since they have so many to choose from. This place is definitely worth a drive and indulge in some great BBQ.
Manuela B.
The food here is outstanding! If you are visiting for the first time. Your waitress will offer a small tasting of their delicious side dishes. The prime rib I had was cooked perfectly. I also recommend trying the garlic pretzels! During dinner the owner and chef walked out into the dining room. He made a point to visit everyone making sure they were happy with their food. I was able to talk with Bob for a few minutes. It was nice to meet the person actually making the food! I can’t wait to visit again. So I can try the rest of the menu.
Rob Z.
Featuring
Catering
Delivery
Dine In
Happy-Hour Food
Great Cocktails
Take Out
Heintzelman's BBQ Pit Rewards
Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online and redeem your points for free food!
Frequently Asked Questions
What are you known for?
We are known for Fries, Macaroni Salad, Coleslaw, Pork, Ribs, Seafood, Cornbread, Mashed Potatoes, Nachos, Pasta, Quesadilla, Bar Food, Tater Tots, BBQ Nachos, Cheeseburger, Potato Salad, Quesadillas, Fried Chicken, Pulled Pork Sandwiches, Baked Potato, Burgers, Southern Food, Wings, Fish, Chicken Sandwich, Brisket, Hamburger, Hot Dogs, Smoked Chicken, Fried Chicken Sandwich, American Food, Pulled Pork Sandwich, Pulled Pork, Poutine, Prime Rib, Shrimp, Chicken Fingers, Fish Fry, Chicken Wings, Chicken, Salads, Baked Beans, and Collard Greens
Where are you located?
We are located in Ontario, NY at 6361 Knickerbocker Rd
What areas do you serve?
We serve the following areas: Ontario Center, Ontario, Furnaceville, Fruitland, Bear Creek, Union Hill, Ontario on the Lake, Walworth, Williamson, Roseland, Pultneyville, West Walworth, Marion, Webster, East Williamson, Gananda, Huddle, Owls Nest, Holland Cove, Penfield Center.
Our location
