THIS IS A NON LIVE LOCATION
Skip to main
Heintzelman's BBQ Pit
  • PopularCurrent Category
  • Appetizers
  • Mac 'N' Cheese
  • Smoked Chicken
  • Pulled Pork
  • Brisket
  • Signature Items
  • Build Your Own
  • Seafood
  • Soups
  • Burger, Hot Dogs, & Hot Links
  • Little Heiny's Club
  • Sides: a la Carte
  • Beverages

Heintzelman's BBQ Pit Menu

6361 Knickerbocker Rd, Ontario, NY

6361 Knickerbocker Rd, Ontario, NY

·

  • PopularCurrent Category
  • Appetizers
  • Mac 'N' Cheese
  • Smoked Chicken
  • Pulled Pork
  • Brisket
  • Signature Items
  • Build Your Own
  • Seafood
  • Soups
  • Burger, Hot Dogs, & Hot Links
  • Little Heiny's Club
  • Sides: a la Carte
  • Beverages

Popular

  • Garlic Parm Pretzels.

    Garlic Parm Pretzels

    $16.00

  • Cut Fries w/Pork.

    Cut Fries w/Pork

    $20.00

  • Garlic Parm Fries.

    Garlic Parm Fries

    $6.00

  • Mac 'N' Cheese.

    Mac 'N' Cheese

    $15.50

  • Broiled Fish Fry.

    Broiled Fish Fry

    $17.00

  • Wings.

    Wings

    $29.00+

Appetizers

Garlic Parm Pretzels

$16.00

Delicious Garlic Parm Pretzels with our house beer cheese

Garlic Parm Pretzels.

Corn Bombs

$12.50

Pop some of these fried cornballs into your mouth if you're looking for a sweet and savory dish. Battered corn kernels in a sugary glaze sauce are a perfect before dinner treat. Served with our homemade buttermilk ranch-sriracha dipping sauce

Corn Bombs.

House Salad

$10.25+

Cornbread croutons, bacon, cherry tomatoes, and red onion with your choice of dressing. Add pulled chicken or pork for an extra charge. Add shredded brisket for an additional charge

House Salad.

Fried Pickle Fries

$12.50

Fried Pickle Fries.

Pit Style BBQ Nachos

$17.00+

Sea salted chips, nacho cheese, olives, tomatoes, onions, Cajun corn, fresco, cheddar cheese, sour cream, jalapenos & original BBQ sauce

Pit Style BBQ Nachos.

Cut Fries w/Pork

$20.00

Seasoned fries, smothered in nacho cheese, sour cream, jalapenos, and original BBQ sauce then topped with our smoked pulled pork

Cut Fries w/Pork.

Cut Fries w/Brisket

$24.00

Seasoned fries, smothered in nacho cheese, sour cream, jalapenos, and original BBQ sauce then topped with our smoked shredded brisket

Cut Fries w/Brisket.

Cut Fries w/Cheese & Bacon

$16.00

Cheddar cheese, sour cream & bacon

Cut Fries w/Chix

$20.00

Poutine

$14.00

Poutine.

Cauliflower

$12.50

Cauliflower.

Quesadilla

$14.00

Quesadilla.

Mac 'N' Cheese

Mac 'N' Cheese

$15.50

Barilla elbow pasta smothered in our 7 cheese blend served as is or add any meat for an extra charge

Mac 'N' Cheese.

Smoked Chicken

Platters come with 2 sides. Single items are only our delicious meat

Pulled Chicken Sandwich

$10.75

Our famous fair style chicken pulled from the bone and tossed in our homemade BBQ. Single items are only our delicious meat

Pulled Chicken Sandwich.

Wings

$29.00+

Single items are only our delicious meat

Wings.

Pulled Chicken Platters

$18.00

1/2 chickens marinated for 24 hours in our special blend of spices, smoked and pulled for your eating pleasure. Platters come with 2 sides

Pulled Pork

Platters come with 2 sides. Single items are only our delicious meat

Pulled Pork Sandwich

$10.75

Single items are only our delicious meat

Ah! Sweet Caroline

$13.00

Single items are only our delicious meat. A Southern twist on our classic pulled pork sandwich. Take the plunge into this juicy sandwich with a pile of coleslaw added on top. The sweetness combined with a punch from the coleslaw will be sure to confuse your taste buds...for the better!

1/2 Slab

$18.40

Single items are only our delicious meat. 6-7 bones

1/2 Slab.

Full Slab

$34.60

Single items are only our delicious meat. 10-12 bones

Full Slab.

32 Hr Pulled Pork Platter

$18.00

Wet and dry rubbed with house blend of 22 spices slow cooked over hickory wood. Platters come with 2 sides

Sweet Caroline Sandwich Platter

$19.00

Pulled pork topped with slaw & original BBQ. Platters come with 2 sides

1/2 Rack St. Louis Ribs Platter

$29.00

6-7 bones. Marinated in our dry rub for 24 hours then slow smoked over hickory wood till pull apart tender. Platters come with 2 sides

1/2 Rack St. Louis Ribs Platter.

Full Rack St. Louis Ribs Platter

$45.00

10-12 bones. Marinated in our dry rub for 24 hours then slow smoked over hickory wood till pull apart tender. Platters come with 2 sides

Full Rack St. Louis Ribs Platter.

Hot Link Platter

$16.00

Brisket

Classic Cut Brisket Sandwich

$15.00

Just the meat

The Little Dickie

$15.50

Just the meat. Originally designed by the owner's son, The Little Dickie takes our brisket sandwich to whole new level! Shredding the brisket over a bed of coleslaw and jalapenos only gets better with a healthy serving of cheddar cheese melted right on top!

The Little Dickie.

Brisket (Prime) Platter

$23.00

House spices, hand rubbed, slow smoked for 12-14 hours

The Little Dickie Platter

$24.00

Brisket sandwich topped with our 4 cheese blend, jalapenos, slaw & original BBQ

The Little Dickie Platter.

Signature Items

Platters come with 2 sides. Single items are only our delicious meat

The Landslide Burger

$15.00

Single items are only our delicious meat. Acting like its' name, this burger is a landslide of meat piled high on a fresh knot roll. Layered with our pulled pork, an Angus smoked cheeseburger, hickory bacon, sauteed onions and jalapenos; this burger is a sure showstopper

Pig Pen Sandwich

$15.00

Single items are only our delicious meat. Want pork, but want to take it a little further? Grab this sandwich and you'll get the best of both worlds. Stacked high on a knot roll lays a bed of fresh homemade slaw, pulled pork, hot link, sauteed onions and hickory bacon

Pig Pen Sandwich.

The Pit Plate

$20.00+

Single items are only our delicious meat. Our BBQ version of the trash plate! Seasoned tater tots, mac salad, smoked baked beans, chopped onions, original BBQ sauce & meat sauce. Choice of 2 meats (hamburger, cheeseburger, hot dog, hot link, pulled pork, pulled chicken)

The Pit Plate.

The Behemoth

$32.40

Single items are only our delicious meat. On a fresh knot roll, we include 2 Angus smoked cheeseburgers, a mountain of pulled pork, a hot link, hickory smoked bacon...and that's just meat! Between the layers you'll find coleslaw, seasoned fries, sauteed onions, jalapenos and BBQ sauce

The Behemoth.

The Landslide Burger Platter

$19.45

Smoked cheeseburger topped with pulled pork, jalapenos, sauteed onions, bacon & original BBQ. Platters come with 2 sides.

The Pig Pen Platter

$18.40

How Link w/ pulled pork, sauteed onions, slaw, bacon & original BBQ. Platters come with 2 sides.

The Pig Pen Platter.

The Mac Daddy Platter

$18.40

Smoked cheeseburger topped with onion rings, smoked mac n cheese, bacon and original BBQ. Platters come with 2 sides.

The Mac Daddy Platter.

Prime Rib Philly Platter

$19.45

Shaved prime rib topped with our 4-cheese blend, sauteed pepper and onions, on a toasted ciabatta roll. Served with house fries. Platters come with 2 sides.

Prime Rib Philly Platter.

Mac 'N' Cheese Dinner Platter

$15.15+

With choice of 2 sides. Add pulled pork, pulled chicken or brisket for an extra charge (each). Platters come with 2 sides.

Mac 'N' Cheese Dinner Platter.

Build Your Own

Create a BBQ Combo - 2 Meats

$30.00

Each BBQ combo comes w/ 2 sides & cornbread, plus your choice of meats: Hot link, pulled pork, pulled chicken, 1/2 smoked chicken (*after 4pm), 4 chicken wings, brisket (with extra charge), 1/2 slab ribs (with extra charge)

Create a BBQ Combo - 2 Meats.

Create a BBQ Combo - 3 Meats

$34.00

Each BBQ combo comes w/ 2 sides & cornbread, plus your choice of meats: Hot link, pulled pork, pulled chicken, 1/2 smoked chicken (*after 4pm), 4 chicken wings, brisket (with extra charge), 1/2 slab ribs (with extra charge)

Create a BBQ Combo - 3 Meats.

Seafood

Platters come with 2 sides. Single items are only our delicious meat

Shrimp Boat

$11.00

Single items are only our delicious meat. 1/2 pound of fried shrimp tossed in our secret HMM sauce and served over lettuce

Shrimp Boat.

Broiled Fish Fry

$17.00

Single items are only our delicious meat

Broiled Fish Fry.

Clam Strips

$10.00

Single items are only our delicious meat. Delicious deep fried clams served with our cocktail sauce and choice of two sides.

Clam Strips.

Breaded Fish

$16.00

Single items are only our delicious meat

Breaded Fish.

Shrimp Platter

$19.00

Panko breaded & butterflied, served with your choice of house made sriracha ranch or house made cocktail sauce & a lemon wedge. Platters come with 2 sides.

Shrimp Platter.

Battered Fish Fry Platter

$21.00

Platters come with 2 sides.

Battered Fish Fry Platter.

Broiled Fish Fry Platter

$22.00

Platters come with 2 sides.

Broiled Fish Fry Platter.

Clam Strips Platter

$18.00

Platters come with 2 sides.

Clam Strips Platter.

Plt-Breaded Fish Platter

$21.00

Platters come with 2 sides.

Plt-Breaded Fish Platter.

Soups

Clam Chowder

$8.00+

A thick, hearty soup consisting of chopped clams, potatoes, and sweet shredded carrots within a milk and cream base.

Clam Chowder.

Burger, Hot Dogs, & Hot Links

Zweigles Red Hot

$8.00

Just the meat.

Fried Chicken Sandwich

$11.00

Just the meat

Fried Chicken Sandwich.

Pit Burgers Platter

$16.00

A special blend of brisket, short rib and chuck, ground and seasoned with our blend of burger salt. Topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, served on a DiPaolo knot roll with a dill pickle spear

Pit Burgers Platter.

Zweigles Red Hot Platter

$13.00

Fried Chicken Sandwich Platter

$18.00

Fried Chicken Sandwich Platter.

Hot Link Platter

$16.00

Little Heiny's Club

Kids 12 years and under. Served with 1 side and a kids drink (water, soda, milk, apple juice)

Chicken Fingers (3)

$12.50

Zweigle's Red Hot

$9.00

Hot Dog Mac N' Cheese

$12.00

Hot Dog Mac N' Cheese.

Pulled Chicken Sandwich

$13.00

Pulled Chicken Sandwich.

Pulled Pork Sandwich

$13.00

Kid Cheeseburger

$12.00

Kid Hamburger

$11.00

Chicken Wings (4)

$14.50

1 sauce.

Sides: a la Carte

Homemade pit style sides

Tater Tots

$6.00

Tater Tots.

Garlic Parm Fries

$6.00

Garlic Parm Fries.

Smoked Mac 'N' Cheese

$6.00

Small. No meat

Smoked Mac 'N' Cheese.

Side Salad

$6.00

With bacon and homemade cornbread croutons

Side Salad.

Spiced Applesauce

$6.00

Spiced Applesauce.

Coleslaw

$6.00

Coleslaw.

Cornbread

$6.00

3 slices

Cornbread.

Mac Salad

$6.00

Mac Salad.

Hand Cut Fries

$6.00

Hand Cut Fries.

Smokey Baked Beans

$6.00

Spicy.

Smokey Baked Beans.

Pork Mac 'N' Cheese

$6.00

With pulled pork and bacon

Pork Mac 'N' Cheese.

Cajun Corn

$6.00

Spicy

Cajun Corn.

Garlic Green Beans

$6.00

Garlic Green Beans.

Baked Potato

$6.00

Beverages

Pepsi Products

$4.00

Pepsi Products.
Heintzelman's BBQ Pit

Menu

Catering

Our Story

Gift Cards

Contact Us

Lunch & Dinner Menu

We're Hiring

Terms of serviceAccessibility

HEINTZELMAN'S BBQ PIT INC. 2026 All Rights Reserved

Powered by Owner